Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Authentic Italian Pizza in Wilmington, NC

Fan of OC's lasagna? Whelp, lemme tell you, i never thought id find a lasagna even CLOSE to OC's. Brooklyn's is now my #1 fave & has a significantly larger serving, and is half the price. Quality consistent as is the cust svc.

Update: It's been two years and I haven't found a better pizza in Wilmington. I've tried others but the quality and consistency of the pies at this shop really are unbeatable. Every time I've asked for a well-done pizza they have absolutely nailed it and their crust is the best.

After several nights of eating down at sit down restaurants in Wilmington, we wanted something low key, so decided to grab some pizza from Brooklyn Pizza Company. They also have a location near UNC Wilmington, but visited this strip mall location on Market Street since it was closer to us and reviews seemed comparable. There are several tables inside for dining in, but it's mainly a take out/delivery type of place as the set up is very utilitarian and functional without much atmosphere. That being said, the service at the counter when ordering and also when receiving food at the table was kind and friendly. We went with an order of garlic cheese bread and a large 18 inch cheese pizza. I have no basis of comparison with regards to quality or price compared to other places in the Wilmington area, but $24 for a simple pizza without toppings seemed a bit expensive. Both items were decent, but wouldn't compete with the quality of pizza ingredients I'm used to in the NJ/NY/PA area. The pizza was cooked well with a great undercarriage, albeit a bit oily, but the cheese, sauce, and crust didn't compare to the great pizza I'm spoiled with back home. That said, nothing was particularly bad, so grading on a regional curve, I'd rate Brooklyn Pizza Company a 3.5/5, which I'm happy to round up since all the employees were friendly, and it was a decent dinner overall.

We ate in. But I'd say it's more of a take out place. Food was good. We had the Sicilian thicker crust pizza which was excellent.

First things first.... I'm a pizza and Italian food snob ( Born and raised in NY ) so I don't steer people to places that don't cut the mustard.... The Pizza is as good as it gets not being in NY Proper. Also their other menu items from the Calzone's to the Stromboli are top-notch.... Take a ride by or get it delivered I sincerely doubt You'll be disappointed......

This is the third time I've ordered from Brooklyn Pizza and I have never been disappointed. I tried something new, and I am very glad I did! They have delicious food, great pricing, and fast service, even on Mother's Day! Thanks guys! I can get a taste of the north here in NC!

We were moving from Wilmington the next day after living here 16 years. Everything was packed so I decided to try Brooklyn Pizza. I wanted to try something different so we called and ordered stuffed shells, veal Parmesan and anti pasta salad. Everything tasted very good. I wish we would have tried them years ago. They are so worth trying out. They gave nice portions for the price. Definitely give them a try.

Pizza really is the best I've had in Wilmington. If you call in the order they text you when it's done - nice feature. Price was reasonable Since we did take out, ambiance didn't come into the equation but nope, you're not coming here for the atmosphere.

I was on a road trip, stopped for the night at a nearby hotel & took a chance on Brooklyn Pizza Co. place an order to be delivered- - excellent decision! person who took my (phone) order was pleasant & very helpful. (I live out of state & knew nothing about this restaurant before tonight.) Our pizza arrived within the promised time. delivery driver was also pleasant & friendly. pizza was delicious! excellent crust & fresh toppings. If I lived anywhere nearby, I'd quickly become "a regular".